There are 2 comments - Display All Comments
GoIrish
Notre Dame, IN
Posted on 10/29/2009 at 10:04:32 AM
Good on ya, Wes - happy you came back and that the family enjoyed the trip! Even though you guys have let us have it good for the last seven years, it’s always nice to have the classy BC fans on campus. I’m biased, of course, but echo your sentiment in every way - there is nothing like a football Saturday “Under the Dome” anywhere in amatuer or pro sports. Thanks for a very nice piece!
BobDavis
Washington, DC
Posted on 10/30/2009 at 6:27:49 PM
Does anyone else see the peculiarity in a school founded by a French order with a French name using the Irish for an identity? And while we’re on that subject, there is nothing traditionally Irish about Scottish kilits, which adds the “Irish” Guard as yet another of the anachronisms of UND. This may be why their rivals sometimes use the term “The Fake Irish” to describe them.
It’s also not clear to me what made you think that the campus is “all done in the classic gothic architecture”. Only a few buildings have vague touches of gothic architecture. In general, the place is a total hodgepodge.
While ND’s Basilica is sort of neo-Gothic the Main Building (with the gold dome) defies classification. It started as French Second Empire, and had so many incoherent ornaments and features added that while the architect called it “Modern Gothic” even ND’s university website says “The building, with its countless angles and corners and jutting points of masonry, the numerous gables and turrets, the classic pillars that support the dome and statue, puzzles anyone who tries to classify it.” The Indiana government calls it “High Victorian Gothic” and says the style was “short lived in popularity, lasting only from about 1875 to 1885 in Indiana.” Touchdown Jesus (which is a mosaic not a mural) is sort of cubist lite, and the School of Architecture building is neo-classical
Ok, so you can classify the campus architecture as “unique” but it seems only it’s architect and the Indiana tourism department would call it “Gothic”.
If you want to visit an American Campus with award-winning Gothic architecture, visit Boston College or Yale.
I’m glad you and your family had a great time.
For my money, I can think of many places I would rather go to see a Boston College game than the middle of a decaying rust belt city in Indiana.
After a game in South Bend, you pretty much want to high tail it out of there and get back to Chicago as fast as possible. When you go to away games in Chapel Hill, Charlottesville, or Clemson, it is actually fun to stick around.
Again, glad you had fun, but really don’t understand the mystique of Notre Dame, or why any good student with the credentials to be accepted would choose a place in the middle of nowhere, with old-style non-coed dorms over Georgetown in Washington DC, or BC in one of the nicest suburbs of America’s biggest college town.

In this day and age of big-time sports and the not-so-good side that often makes the headlines, I want to share with you my latest good news story about big-time college football.
E-mail Story
Print Story
