Challenges of President 44

So we’ve just passed the fourth anniversary of the day President Bush declared major Iraq combat operations over. This is as good a time as any to ponder what the 44th U.S. president will have to do to reverse the foreign policy mistakes of the 43rd.

This new course isn’t as easy to describe as some Democratic candidates pretend. Chances are President Bush will pass the Iraq dilemma on to his successor in 2009.

But one thing is not in doubt. Poll figures for confidence in President Bush’s international leadership from countries in Europe, Asia and the Middle East are so low that President 44 will have to struggle to reassert America’s global standing.

Author and commentator Zbigniew Brzezinski (Jimmy Carter’s national security adviser) takes an interesting look at how the next president might approach that Herculean task in his new book, "Second Chance: Three Presidents and the Crisis of American Superpower."

Brzezinski faults all three presidents of the post-Cold War era for failing to capitalize on our unique standing as "Global Leader" after the Soviet Union collapsed. Bush I, to whom he assigns a grade of B, failed to take advantage of a swift victory in the 1991 Gulf War to push hard for a Middle Eastern peace accord. Bill Clinton, awarded a C, was wrong to assume that globalization would solve world problems rather than exacerbate tensions.


Bush II, an F, adopted a doctrine focused on unilateral military action, pursuing "a self-declared existential struggle against the forces of evil." Yet, ironically, his moral certainty wound up undermining America’s moral stature:

So how can President 44 restore America’s standing as a leader, both on the soft-power front — where America leads by example — and as a leader on the military front?

On the soft-power side, Brzezinski believes that globalization of information has made people around the world far more aware of social and economic gaps.

Another "dramatic issue" is ecology. The next president must not only push to curb carbon emissions at home, but must also seek ways to provide China and India with clean energy technology they can afford.

For Brzezinski, the next president must demonstrate the United States is "a genuine partner for the world community.’’ On the hard-power side, Brzezinski believes the world still wants and needs American leadership.

He wants the next president to work hard to repair our alliance with the fellow democratic nations of Europe. This president would fight Islamist terrorists, but stop whipping up Americans’ fear by using the incorrect term "war on terror."

And Brzezinski wants Bush to organize serious Mideast regional talks.

This is a test that President 43 is failing. In the end, the ability of President 44 to revamp America’s global image may depend on the size of the Iraq mess he inherits from Bush.


Trudy Rubin is a columnist and editorial-board member for the Philadelphia Inquirer. Her e-mail address is

What To Read Next
Fundraising is underway to move the giant ball of twine from the Highland, Wisconsin, home of creator James Frank Kotera, who died last month at age 75, 44 years after starting the big ball.