ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

Re-enactments wrongly glorify war

The April 26 Post-Bulletin had a half-page story with photos of a civil war reenactment to occur in Mantorville on May 1 and 2 (pictures in the May 4 paper). One of the participants called it "family friendly — something you can bring your kids to."

Previously, in the Dec. 5-6 weekend edition, the P-B had a full page photo essay, mostly pictures, of 25 boys, third through sixth grade, who did a civil war re-enactment in mid-October. One fourth-grader was quoted: "I had a lot of fun in the war…" An insert said "Kudos (to the organizer)… to learn about the Civil War in such a fun way..."

The civil war: Fun?

Do these events tell the reality of the civil war: at least 600,000 soldiers died; the First Maine artillery unit lost 635 of 900 men in the first seven minutes in one battle; the First Minnesota regiment lost 75 percent of its men; one Virginia family had 18 family members die; the terrible damage inflicted by Sherman's march to the sea from Atlanta to Savannah Georgia?

These re-enactments sanitize and glorify the Civil War. They subtly contribute to the acceptance of war and the culture of violence all too prevalent in our society today.

ADVERTISEMENT

Rich Van Dellen

Rochester

What To Read Next
Get Local

ADVERTISEMENT