Letter: Important differences between FOIA and Minn. Data Practices Act

There are important differences between FOIA and MGDPA.

Letter to the Editor graphic
We are part of The Trust Project.

The recent “Our View” (Rochester School District Data Practices request from Equality in Education) appeared to be hastily written.

The editorial focuses too much on the Federal Freedom of Information Act (FOIA), when the request is actually under the Minnesota Government Data Practices Act (MGDPA). Two different laws, with a similar general theme, but differences in how they are carried out. FOIA is “baked into” executive branch agencies, meaning their data and record-keeping methods assume that a FOIA request could occur. Too often, agencies under laws like MGDPA fail to do this, even though technology (like Google Classroom) should make it far less complex and time-consuming than is claimed. And so excuses like “teachers should be teaching” and outrageous fees are used to avoid compliance with the law.

One recent study showed only 7.6% of FOIA requests come from journalists. I wonder why that is. Lack of interest? See Batya Ungar-Saryon's recent book.

Just spit-balling here, but do the number of MGDPA and FOIA requests track polls showing the decline in public trust of government agencies over the past several decades?

Editors throw gas on the fire by claiming Critical Race Theory is an old, law school enterprise, not taught in schools, etc. (Tip: No one, including Equality in Education, thinks schools are teaching classes on Critical Race Theory using the Delgado/Stefancic text. Editors should at least make a ninth-grade attempt at understanding the issue.)


Steve Boe, La Grande, Ore. (formerly Bemidji)

What to read next
We appreciate the PB's willingness to print letters to editor voicing our personal perspectives. While they allow us to vent, they are very limited and inadequate for facilitating meaningful honest discussion and for discerning truth. Vague and false portrayals of our candidates have been made here and printed by the PB.
I am thinking they should change the name of the US Mail to Mystery Mail because you never know when you are going to get it. It is now three days with no mail delivery and when I do get mail often it belongs to someone else. Oh! The mail truck did go by two days in a row but the lady said she was doing packages only.
The previous administration proved that good policies and competent people produce good results. Examples being: energy independence, secure borders, low inflation, robust economy, cheap gas and food, and a well functioning country.
Considering what is going on with the budget surplus, can the withholding of these funds be seen as fraud or embezzlement? Remember this is your money and my money.